A4NH / Africa / Agri-Health / Bird flu / Books and Chapters / Climate Change / Disease Control / Emerging Diseases / FSZ / Health / ILRI / RVF / Spotlight / Zoonotic Diseases

African Animal Annals: Deadly trifecta of climate change, population and disease?


PendergastOlivia_MalawiBoyAndChicken

All fine artwork on this page is by Olivia Pendergast (see note below for more information).

In the last quarter of 2014 a book was published and launched on climate change and public health. Edited by Colin Butler, of the University of Canberra, and published by CABI, the book brings together 56 authors from 19 countries. Unfortunately, the book lies behind a paywall. You can buy the 328-page hardback volume from CABI here.

Climate Chang and Global Health book cover

Chapter 23, on ‘Zoonotic diseases and their drivers in Africa’, is written by Delia Grace (Irish) and Bernard Bett (Kenyan), two veterinarians and veterinary epidemiologists working for the International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI) in Nairobi, Kenya. Here’s how Grace and Bett introduce their subject.

Currently, around 24 billion livestock (19 billion of them in poor countries) provide food, income and other products and services for around 7 billion people (5 billion of whom are in poor countries) . . . .

Animals provide income, nutrition, security and psychological benefits. But food that nourishes can contain pathogens that kill; manure that grows crops can poison water; and livestock that survive better than crops in unpredictable climates produce greenhouse gases (GHGs) that contribute to climate change.

The current numbers of both livestock and people are of orders of magnitude greater than ecosystems have ever previously been required to support, and nowhere are numbers changing faster than in Africa, the cradle of humanity.

The relationships between livestock keeping and human well-being are multiple and complex . . . . This chapter focuses on one of the most important relationships; that is, the link between livestock and zoonoses in the context of sub-Saharan Africa. . . .

Around one in three of poor African families keeps livestock. There is debate as to whether the popularity of livestock keeping among the poor is a pathway out of poverty or a mechanism and expression of it (Perry and Grace, 2009), destined to be replaced by highly intensive, and impersonal, livestock systems (Dijkman, 2009), as has happened in other continents. . . .

The persistence of poverty in Africa, the high proportion of poor families who keep livestock and the relative low level of agricultural intensification and input use have implications for the emergence and persistence of zoonoses in this continent.

The rest of this chapter focuses on aspects of zoonoses in ecosystems of most importance to Africa. These include the high vulnerability to endemic zoonoses and the relative protection from the outbreak zoonoses associated with livestock intensification. Also distinct to the populations of this enormous and diverse region are the high dependence on wild-caught ‘bushmeat’ and the exceptional vulnerability to a deadly trifecta of climate change, high rates of demographic increase and uncontrolled disease. . . .

Given greater contact with animal carriers and inadequate health services for diagnosis and treatment, it is not surprising that people in poor countries are much more at risk from zoonoses: a recent study estimated that in least developed countries (mostly African), the relative burden of zoonoses and diseases recently emerged from animals was 500 times greater than the burden of these diseases in rich countries (Grace et al., 2012b). . . .

We can think of rapidly intensifying and unregulated livestock systems as ‘hot spots’, where development and rapid change surpass the speed of the Industrial Revolution, threatening animal and perhaps human health in ways never seen before. . . .

In contrast, an entirely different set of health problems threaten ‘cold spots’ throughout much of Africa, areas locked in a time warp of underdevelopment and crippled by old diseases. . . .

Yet policy and funding is often driven by the concerns of the ‘worried well’ in rich countries, and even in Africa, diseases of intensification that are unlikely to establish receive more attention and support than the silent epidemic of old-fashioned zoonoses that reliably kill and sicken on a large scale. This inevitably diverts funding and scarce human resources from the diseases of the poor. . . .

[I]ncreasing wealth could trump increasing warmth (Perry and Grace, 2009). The history of humanity started in Africa, and Africa has a key role, not only as a custodian of irreplaceable resources but also as a tipping point from where the world’s future can get dramatically worse or start to improve.’

PendergastOlivia_MalawiManAndCow

All fine artwork on this page is by Olivia Pendergast (see note below for more information).

Below are a smattering of other salient points, as posted on Twitter (here in chronological order).

Zoonotic diseases & their drivers in Africa-chapter by @DeliaGrace4 & @bett_bk
in ‘Climate Change & Global Health’ http://bit.ly/144FdkR 

  • 24bn livestock (19bn in poor countries) feed 7bn people (5bn in poor countries)
  • # of livestock & people are orders of magnitude greater than ecosystems have ever supported
  • Nowhere r numbers of livestock & people changing faster than in Africa, cradle of humanity
  • Living with the Enemy: Proximity to livestock and other animals fosters pathogen access
  • Even in urban Nairobi, Kenya, 1 in 80 households keeps dairy cows & 1 in 8 keeps pigs
  • The poor eat less meat/milk than the rich but their slaughter/eating habits are riskier
  • Pathogens can travel around the world in less time than the incubation period of a disease
  • Chickens are coming home to roost: Zoonotic pandemics 1997–2009 cost rich countries >US$80bn
  • Risks of eating your relatives: Esp risky 4 new diseases r animals related closely to humans
  • Horsemen of the Apocalypse do not ride alone: Deadly trifecta of climate, demography, disease
  • ‘Lethal gifts of livestock’: Measles, smallpox, diphtheria (TB apparently went the other way)
  • Other civilization-altering zoonotic crises: Bubonic plague, smallpox, measles, Spanish flu
  • A warmer, wetter, poorer world is likely to be a sicker world & Africa is vulnerable to climate change
  • We risk creating in Africa an ideal milieu for the emergence & propagation of new diseases

Acknowledgements

‘This work ‘Dynamic Drivers of Disease in Africa: Ecosystems, livestock/wildlife, health and wellbeing: NE-J001570-1’ was partly funded with support from the Ecosystem Services for Poverty Alleviation Programme (ESPA). The ESPA programme is funded by the Department for International Development (DFID), the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC). Other funding was provided by CGIAR Research Program Agriculture for Nutrition and Health.’

PendergastOlivia_MalawiBoyAndGoat

Fine artwork by Olivia Pendergast

Please visit the home page of American artist Olivia Pendergast, based in Seattle and formally known as ‘Holly Mae’, to see her galleries titled Malawi figuratives 1 and Malawi figurative 2 for more of her fine artwork series from, and inspired by, her African journeys.

More information

For more information, please email Delia Grace (d.grace [at] cgiar.org) or Bernard Bett (b.bett [at] cgiar.org).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s